Robin Hood Season Three DVD Review – Win Yours Here

The BBC series Robin Hood started with a bang. The introduction to the story was solidly put together, the characters were infinitely likable, and the general feel of syndicated adventure was delivered with more style than most were accustomed to from such an effort. Jonas Armstrong's Robin was just about everything you could hope for in the suave bandit, and as time went on, Richard Armitage's Gisborne was a major henchman you could sink your teeth into.

However, as we approached the end of the first season, and made our way into the second, things started to fizzle. The episodic plots were sometimes rather trivial, the overall drama took center stage, and week after week found us trying to invest in an A-Team-esque display of perpetual fighting with zero result, and the Sheriff nonsensically living to fight another day. The eventual Gisborne/Robin/Marian triangle was overplayed, and as the end of season two approached, things were boring at best.

Perhaps seeing the downward spiral, season three is practically a reboot of sorts. Marian is dead, and the show returns with a darker feel, a darker Robin, and episodic and seasonal arcs that are miles more interesting. Focusing much more on intrigue and serious plotting, the days of fairly silly fighting and escape are over.

While still a fairly light, adventure showcase, the show has never been better than season three. Now with Prince John himself showing up, and the inclusion of Tuck, we have a more engaging play of characters. As the story rolls along toward more serious conflict, the writers have found a surer foothold on holding interest. The Sheriff very nearly killing Robin, but soon shaking his fist in the air doesn't work as long was originally believed.

Your Ad Here

The DVD release of season three comes with nearly an hour of bonus features, and while there might have been a bit more meat to them, they are a nice group of extras. A Legend Reborn is more or less your straight Behind-the-Scenes sort of featurette, but with an emphasis on turning things around for the third season. It's biggest selling point is probably the look at the new characters, and the discussion on reinventing things with a really pissed off Robin. A New Look is a featurette on the costume design, and while that may be about all you can say about it, it's more interesting than you think. Another featurette, Trebuchet: Creating Chaos, is pretty self-explanatory, and there are Character Profiles and Video Diaries thrown into the mix as well. Special features are always difficult, because people have their own leanings, but video diaries always strike me as a great bonus, and these are a welcome addition here. Fans are going to enjoy seeing the cast, and as video diaries go, these are a bit more than the slapped-together efforts you sometimes get.

Overall, this is a release that I'd give about four out of five stars. If you've caught the show at all, this is the season to own, and frankly, you could start here as well.

Own it on DVD today!

Leave a comment below and include the word, "Win," and you are automatically entered to get your very own copy of the DVD release. U.S. only. Winner will be randomly selected March 1st.

Check out a few clips below.

RU?

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

© 2010, Are You Screening?. All rights reserved. Reprinting without express permission of the author is prohibited.

Play
Follow us on Twitter

About Marc Eastman

Marc Eastman is the owner and operator of Are You Screening? and has been writing film reviews for over a decade, and several branches of the internet's film review world have seen his name. His reviews have brought him personal praise from the director of a major motion picture, and have been used as required reading in a course at a major University. These priceless rewards, along with just bags of cash, keep him from straying from freelance writing. He is also a member of The Broadcast Film Critics Association and The Broadcast Television Journalists Association.

Twitter | Facebook | More Posts (1450)
  • Quinn

    I can't be the first one to do this–yet I see no other comments–but: Win. Please?

    I agree that the show went downhill, but I do not think it became trite during Season 2. Rather, I believe the stakes got higher as there bloomed relationships that weren't expected–and they further complicated things. Plus, the Sheriff wanted to take over more than just Nottingham, by the end of Season 1.

    I know I was the most tense in Season 2–freaking out over whether or not Marian would be found out. Then Season 3 came along, and it was like Season 2 on steroids: more actions and more twists in the plot–but the same amount of time in which to do it. Plus, they introduced all these new characters–none of whom were as incredibly likeable as the original characters.

    I still enjoyed Season 3 a lot, though–mostly, that's because I enjoyed the Guy of Gisborne drama and the huge shift that took place in his very nature. I started watching Robin Hood because I liked Richard Armitage, so I was pleased with the spotlight he got on Season 3, despite the fact that it was cloying and melodramatic most of the time.

  • Mye Kaew

    I want to WIN. Thanks!

  • Heather

    Great show! I would love to win this!

  • Stacey Vinson

    Win

  • Anonymous

    Richard Armitage is THE most spectacular man on the planet; I NEED to WIN so I can maintain my drool quota every day:)

  • Tully

    It was most entertaining watching Sir Guy try to win the heart of Lady Marian in the first two seasons. I didn't much mind saying goodbye to Marian as long as Guy was still in the picture, and was he EVER in season three. Without Armitage, the show would have faded long before season three.

  • Julie

    I love Richard Armitage! Would love to win this. :)

  • http://twitter.com/brailroad N.G.S.

    I started watching this series just for Guy of Gisborne. I bought the season one in blu ray dvd. Why are the rest of the seasons not released in blu ray?? I am a huge fan of Richard Armitage and would love to WIN a copy of season 3.
    thanks

  • Anonymous

    Richard Armitage, my absolute favorite actor in the entire universe, is the reason I stuck with the show through three seasons. RH on BBCA is where I discovered him and he turned what could have been a cartoonish cardboard henchman into an amazing, complex character. Yes, far too much time was spent in S3 building up new characters not nearly as appealing as the original ones . . . the writers sometimes seemed to be smoking something funny (I actually wondered if they had watched the show before writing their eps) . . . but the combination of Richard’s performance as the deconstructed and then redeemed Sir Guy, Toby Stephen’s delicious Prince John and Keith Allen’s marvelously nasty sheriff kept you watching. A wonderful guest appearance by Holliday Grainger in one ep will make you cry. Oh, and win (and I would love to!)

  • http://www.armitageblog.blogspot.com/ Natalie

    Win Win Win! :)

  • Lynn M.

    For me, only Richard Armitage as Guy of Gisborne, and Toby Stephens as Prince John made season 3 watchable. While I appreciated the darker nature of the writing and plots, the writers just didn't go far enough. They couldn't seem to decide if they were writing for children (hang gliding? decrepit circus-reject lions as weapons?), or writing for thinking adults. Initially, I was excited to know they were finally going to write Tuck into the program, but all we got from him was boring speechifying ad nauseum. And then we had the addition of the token female gang member, Kate, who was simply awful and impossible to watch. Season 3 was about wasted opportunities, with a few notable exceptions. Gisborne's scenes were dark, tormented, and fascinating to watch, as were Prince John's “over the top by any other actor but pulled off by Toby Stephens” moments. Perhaps when the Robin Hood producers decided to rework this show, they should have run with its strength and renamed it the “Guy of Gisborne” show. There was a character whose journey could have been even more fascinating given the opportunity and much stronger scripts.

    Oh, and…WIN! :-)

  • GabbyLowe

    I love Robin Hood-I would love to win.

  • Cindy Brown

    Win Please !!!
    I enjoyed all 3 seasons of Robin Hood and miss the show greatly. Season 3 explains why Guy had such bitterness t.oward Robin and the people of Locksley

  • http://twitter.com/LSM71059 LSM71059

    Win..

  • Mary

    season 3 renews your hope and I enjoyed it very much. so much I’d like to win it!

  • Andrea

    I think season 3 was a Win Win for Robin Hood. It will mbe missed.

  • Anonymous

    I loved Season 3 and I agree, Season 2 was just not as good. I think by the time the writers got to Season 2 they realized they had a problem. The fans loved Guy of Gisborne and by the end of Season 1 Marian had left Guy and oops – there goes our story. The attempts to work her back into Guy’s good graces while keeping a relationship with Robin just didn’t ring true. She genuinely cared for Guy in Season 1 and regardless of how often she said it in Season 2 – she obviously was stringing him along for information. Season 3 was better. There was conflict within and without for Robin and Guy. Richard Armitage really has a way of presenting that conflict – you see his torment and pain yet you see the pride and confidence he displayed before the Sheriff, the Prince and his sister. The villian stole this show from the legend, no doubt and entirely due to the great acting of Armitage. Their discovery of kinship and subsequent partnering for the good of the cause was well done albeit a bit to sudden. More time should have been spent developing that storyline but Britsh shows have such short seasons! I would love to WIN Season 3 on DVD since the rest of my family won’t let me take up DVR space saving all the episodes!

  • Anonymous

    This show brought me Richard Armitage and for that I am grateful! I have Season 1 & 2 so I really want to WIN Season 3. Thank you!

  • areyouscreening

    Thanks for the comment.

    Well, maybe not trite, but many of the episodes were pretty boring… that could be just me.

    I appreciate you adding to the conversation.

  • areyouscreening

    I actually rather agree. But, whether things were occasionally fairly crazy, at least they were different.

    I'm hearing both sides in the comments (which is great), but season 3 was a lot more watchable for me.

    Thanks for the comment.

  • Anonymous

    I loved season three, and I would love to “Win” this!

  • Anonymous

    Any season of Robin Hood would win my vote for an award for entertaining, fun, witty, and great TV. Though I’ll own this regardless of whether I win or not, as I am a poor student, winning anything at all would be quiet nice.

  • Craig Edgerton

    I just started watching RH Season I and thoroughly enjoyed! Of course I have a numerous questions and frustrations with the storyline, but overall enjoy the characters. I am currently watching the DVD’s through Netflix, and look forward to SII and III, but am already disappointed seeing that the show ends with SIII.

    My one big question is…does anyone else have an issue with the fact that in SI, Episode 2, there were over a dozen of “Merrymen” but then by Episode 3 there was half as many?

  • Craig Edgerton

    Win!

    I just started watching RH Season I and thoroughly enjoyed! Of course I have a numerous questions and frustrations with the storyline, but overall enjoy the characters. I am currently watching the DVD's through Netflix, and look forward to SII and III, but am already disappointed seeing that the show ends with SIII.

    My one big question is…does anyone else have an issue with the fact that in SI, Episode 2, there were over a dozen of “Merrymen” but then by Episode 3 there was half as many?

  • Heather H.

    I love this show, and I would love to WIN a copy of the 3rd season! Richard Armitage has become one of my favorite actors, thanks to this show, which introduced me to the talented Mr. Armitage! I would love to add this season to my “Robin Hood” collection!!

  • Donna

    I have enjoyed Seasons 1 and 2 of Robin Hood via streaming Netflix. I would love to WIN the season 3 DVDs before they come via my DVD list – where it says “very long wait”.

  • susanbutler

    i love the bbc show robin hood. i love it when i saw it on tv. i loce to win the dvd.

  • susanbutler

    i love to win this dvd. i love the show very much

  • Diane

    I originally watched the show expecting to find Robin (Jonas Armstrong) as the most compelling character, but was quickly seduced by the complexity of Guy (Richard Armitage) and the humor of the Sherriff (Keith Allen). I really enjoyed the added darkness of season 3, but found Kate (Joanne Frogatt) to be an annoyance – the character was just the “token girl” and added nothing to the company or the season's arc.

  • LissaCTR

    I love this show and would love to “WIN” season 3 on DVD!

  • LissaCTR

    I love this show! Robin is the best. I would love to “WIN” season 3 on DVD!

  • wistfulvista

    This was a great series — a fresh take on the Robin Hood story. Sometimes it strains believability and fails to develop the story and the characters with any depth, but it's just so much fun! The good guys are a little rowdy and the bad guys are deliciously bad, and the sexy Guy of Gisborne's multilayered, conflicted character redeems the show from being just fluffy kids' stuff.

    I'd love to be the one to win the dvd!

  • LissaCTR

    Today is my birthday and I would love to “Win” Robin Hood. What a great present that would be. :)

  • Pingback: RichardArmitageNet News » Blog Archive » February 2010 news archive